Rocking Covers: Simon vs Disturbed

Rocking Covers - Simon vs Disturbed

Alright, let’s dive into this like a fucking champ. First off, "The Sound of Silence" by Simon and Garfunkel, a goddamn timeless classic, right? Written by Paul Simon in the aftermath of JFK's assassination, the song originally flopped harder than a fish out of water when it was first released in 1964. But lo and behold, thanks to the mysterious machinations of the music industry and a bit of remix magic without the duo's initial consent, it became a massive hit in 1965. The song is poetry, pure and simple, weaving themes of isolation, alienation, and the inability to communicate into a folk-rock tapestry that's as haunting as it is beautiful.

Enter Disturbed, decades later, with frontman David Draiman. Now, these guys are typically associated with that hard-hitting, nu-metal bash-your-head-against-the-wall kind of vibe, not melancholy ballads. But fuck me, didn’t they just turn expectations on their head? When Disturbed released their cover in 2015, it was like someone took the original, injected it with steroids, and blasted it through a wall of sound. It’s deeper, darker, and has a kind of apocalyptic urgency that Simon and Garfunkel's version, while contemplative and brooding, doesn’t quite hit.

Now, let’s talk about David Draiman’s fucking masterstroke, shall we? The bloke took a song that’s essentially very subdued and acoustic, and transformed it into a powerful rock ballad that maintains the original’s melancholic soul but amps up the intensity to eleven. Draiman’s voice, that gravelly, operatic powerhouse, carries a weight that adds a layer of desperation and a call to action that the original, for all its poetic beauty, doesn’t scream at you.

The contrasting styles are bloody fascinating: Simon and Garfunkel’s version is almost ethereal, gentle guitar strums accompanying their soft, harmonious vocals, inviting you to listen quietly in the dark. Disturbed, on the other fucking hand, makes you want to stand up and march, possibly into a storm, with Draiman’s voice leading the charge. It’s no longer just a lament; it’s a wake-up call, a rallying cry against the very silence they’re singing about.

What Draiman did brilliantly was not just cover a song; the guy gave it a new identity while respecting the original's soul. It’s a rare thing when a cover does more than just mimic—it reinterprets, reshapes, and even challenges how we perceive the original. Some purists might argue that it’s too much, too dramatic, or too different, but that’s the fucking beauty of music and interpretation. It keeps the conversation alive.

So, to wrap this rant up, both versions are masterpieces in their own right. Simon and Garfunkel’s track fits perfectly with the disillusionment of the '60s, while Disturbed’s rendition speaks to the chaotic, noisy despair of our current age. David Draiman didn’t just cover a song; he seized it, redefined it, and slapped it back into the collective consciousness of a new generation. Now, that’s how you fucking do a cover.

Other Music Reviews